Hello dear
Welcome To Yellow Tavern
Welcome to Yellow Tavern, a charming eatery nestled in the heart of New Harmony, Indiana. This lively spot is renowned for its diverse menu, featuring mouthwatering sandwiches, from juicy hamburgers to perfectly grilled chicken breasts. Patrons rave about their pizzas, praised for fresh toppings and a perfectly baked crust. The inviting atmosphere is adorned with local decorations, creating a cozy dining experience. Although it operates on a cash-only basis, an ATM is conveniently located on-site. Whether you’re craving a hearty meal or a refreshing beer, Yellow Tavern captures the essence of communal dining with heartfelt dishes that leave a lasting impression.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Chicken Tenders
Hawaiian Pizza
US$14.25Bud Light
Smithwicks
Labatt Blue
Stella Artois
Moosehead
Blue Moon
Michelob Amberbock
About
Yellow Tavern
Welcome to Yellow Tavern, a gem nestled in the heart of New Harmony, Indiana. Located at 521 Church St, this charming eatery is a must-visit for both locals and travelers seeking an inviting dining atmosphere paired with delectable dishes. With a delightful array of menu offerings, there's something for everyone, from succulent meats to flavorful vegetarian options.
At Yellow Tavern, their entrée selection shines brightly. The Choice TBone and Choice Ribeye are standout favorites, grilled to perfection with a sear that keeps diners coming back for more. Seafood enthusiasts will delight in the Grilled Atlantic Salmon and Fantail Breaded Shrimp, both delivering a taste of the ocean that complements the tavern's rustic charm.
Beyond the entrées, the sides truly enhance the dining experience. Picture a plate filled with Homemade German Potato Salad or a generous Large House Salad, adding freshness to your meal. Customers rave about the oven-fresh French Fries and the hearty Baked Potato, which are perfect accompaniments to any dish ordered.
Yellow Tavern has garnered a cult following for its pizza, often hailed as the best in town. With a focus on fresh toppings and an expertly crafted crust, it’s a must-try item. As noted by satisfied patrons, "the toppings are fresh and the crust was just right," creating a memorable pie that many fondly remember from their childhood.
What makes Yellow Tavern even more appealing is its welcoming atmosphere, decorated with local memorabilia that tells a story of community and heritage. It’s a place where friends and family gather to share stories over a comforting meal. Despite being a cash-only establishment, an ATM is conveniently located on-site, ensuring a hassle-free experience for diners.
If you're craving a casual dining experience with a homely touch, Yellow Tavern is the spot. Whether you prefer a hearty steak, fresh seafood, or a classic pizza, this tavern promises satisfaction in every bite. Make your way to New Harmony and discover why this local treasure is frequently lauded as the ultimate dining destination. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ As a Plantbased cedar, it’s difficult to find food out in most areas. This place made a delicious vegetable wrap served with potato chips, but for someone who is really hungry it hit the spot. My brother had a grilled cheese sandwich with the customized with sliced tomato. He liked the coleslaw. We both had a beer. ”
“ Yellow Tavern is THE place to go while in New Harmony. The sear on their steak is perfect every time. CASH ONLY but an ATM is available by the restrooms. A little pricey as everything is a la carte but the food is so good! Everybody raves about their pizza so be sure to try it. All the desserts are homemade. MUST BE 21 ”
“ We love their pizza. The toppings are fresh and the crust was just right. Great food! ”
“ YUM YUM! For gluten-free diet: I recommend the grilled chicken breast, no bun. Great food and atmosphere. I love the local decorations. Limited seating. Cash only for payment, but there is an ATM onsite. ”
“ If you're in New Harmony this is where you need to stop for lunch / dinner. We met family at "The Yellow" for a Christmas Eve-Eve dinner, excellent as usual and not just the food but decorations too. All were pleased with their meals, I can tell you my pizza was loaded with toppings. (Way back in the day this was the only place you could get pizza locally, what a great memory) Tavern fills up on Friday and Saturday evenings so I suggest you get there early. I highly recommend. ”
“ Such a cute quaint place. We enjoyed a supreme pizza and split a salad. The blue cheese salad dressing had chunks of cheese in it. A friend enjoyed a cod sandwich which was huge. No draft beers, but a large variety of bottles. Best part of the Yellow Tavern was the service. Our waitress practically read our minds when our water glasses ran low. ”
“ The Yellow Tavern has a cozy atmosphere in the beautiful town of New Harmony, Indiana. They offer a nice selection of spirits and tasty food items. Their pizza is great, along with their steaks and homemade dessert of the day. Cash only. Popular restaurant. ”
“ We love to come here and eat and enjoy the atmosphere! Brenda is a great server, I've been acquainted with her for several years and she does a great job! Today, which was Kunstfest 2019 was a busy day, but The Yellow Tavern ran like a well oiled machine! We had cheeseburgers and breaded cauliflower which is always delicious! ”